Young man in covid-19 testing center outdoors on street

Nucleic Acid Detection Methods for Respiratory Pathogens

 

With the rapid development and convergence of cutting-edge disciplines including genomics, engineering, and nanoscience, Nucleic Acid Amplification Tests (NAATs) have evolved into diverse detection methods with continuously advancing technologies. These tests have played a crucial role in the global response to the COVID-19 pandemic and have become the reference standard for diagnosing SARS-CoV-2 infections. Faced with numerous testing methods, clinicians and microbiology laboratories must carefully evaluate when to choose which method or combination of methods. The determining factors include epidemiology, laboratory resources, workflow processes, and testing costs. The performance characteristics of different respiratory pathogen nucleic acid detection technologies are compared in the table below.

 

Table: Comparison of Nucleic Acid Detection Technologies

Technology Method Performance Characteristics Application Commercial Reagents
Real-time fluorescent PCR Pathogens: Single
Throughput: Batch testing, high
Detection limit: 100-1000 copies/mL
TAT: ≈1.5-3h
Outpatient/Emergency screening, mass population screening Available
Multiplex PCR Pathogens: Several to dozens
Throughput: Batch testing, medium
Detection limit: 1000 copies/mL
TAT: ≈1.5-3h
Epidemiological investigation, hospital-acquired severe pneumonia, community-acquired pneumonia, mixed infections Available
Isothermal amplification Pathogens: 1 to several
Throughput: Variable
Detection limit: 100-1000 copies/mL
TAT: ≈0.5-1.5h
Fever clinics, emergency departments, point-of-care testing Available
Digital PCR Pathogens: 1 to dozens
Throughput: 4-7 specimens
Detection limit: 1 copy/mL
TAT: ≈3-4h
Quantitative detection, therapeutic evaluation, environmental testing, reference/standard calibration Available
Point-of-care nucleic acid testing Pathogens: 1 to several
Throughput: Variable
Detection limit: 100-1000 copies/mL
TAT: ≈0.5-1.5h
Fever clinics, emergency departments, bedside testing Available
Pathogen metagenomics high-throughput sequencing Pathogens: Unknown, unlimited
Throughput: 10-16/chip
Detection limit: ≈1000 copies/mL
TAT: ≈18-24h
Complex severe cases undiagnosable by traditional pathogen detection Not available
Multiplex pathogen targeted sequencing Pathogens: Dozens to hundreds of known pathogens and their virulence/resistance genes
Throughput: Variable
Detection limit: 25-500 copies/mL
TAT: ≈18-24h
Outpatient/Emergency, fever clinics, general wards, ICU, recurrent respiratory infection investigation Not available

 

With the numerous pathogen detection technologies available today, selecting appropriate testing methods to better address clinical issues has become a crucial topic in achieving precision diagnosis and treatment of infectious diseases. Experts point out: "Different pathogen diagnostic methods each have their own applicable scenarios and prerequisites. The selection of suitable testing methods should be based on patient population, disease characteristics, suspected pathogen types, and local laboratory capabilities."

Mantacc continues to innovate in enriching its flocked swab product portfolio and providing comprehensive solutions for multiple testing scenarios, striving to meet dynamic market demands. For different clinical applications, Mantacc offers a range of flocked swabs based on varying collection requirements, providing integrated solutions for precise clinical diagnostics.

For high-complexity testing environments, our premium flocked swabs feature superior sample collection and release rates, capable of handling over 95% specimen recovery. For routine clinical testing and hospital settings, our standard flocked swab series combines versatility with cost-effectiveness, efficiently collecting common respiratory, nasal, and throat specimens. For point-of-care testing scenarios, our rapid-test compatible swabs offer immediate sampling capabilities, supporting fast and accurate diagnostics.

 

Related posts

Everything You Need To Know About Flocked Swabs